Electric vs. Diesel Aerial Work Platforms: What’s Right for Your Worksite?
While the reach of aerial lifts is certainly a critical factor, it is not the only aspect of the machine that matters. For a platform to be suitable for the environment it will operate in, it has to meet the worksite’s power requirements.
Operators and facility managers typically have two engine options to choose from - diesel and electric. Both models bring their own unique advantages, limitations, and use cases. It is critical to understand each of them so the right platform can be used at the right worksite.
In today’s blog, Platform Basket Canada – North America’s top supplier of aerial work platforms- will illustrate how these two engine types perform across various conditions, thus contributing to the safety and efficiency of different worksites.
Understanding Electric Aerial Work Platforms
Electric aerial work platforms are powered by batteries, enabling plug-and-play performance in environments that require quiet operations, such as indoor or controlled worksites.
The best working conditions for electric aerial work platforms include:
- Manufacturing plants
- Warehouses and distribution centers
- Maintenance work in enclosed spaces
- Commercial buildings
- Noise-sensitive areas such as hospitals, schools, and residential spaces
Key advantages: With zero emissions and quiet operations built into their design, electric aerial lifts allow operators to safely work in environments that put strict limitations on noise levels and air pollution. They typically provide smoother operation as well, making them a great choice for tasks that require controlled movements and high-level precision, such as installation work and maintenance tasks.
Limitations: Electric models are not without their constraints. Since they depend on built-in batteries for operation, the life of the battery can restrict active work time. Plus, worksites must feature a compliant and compatible charging outlet so these machines can be charged onsite for uninterrupted operations.
Understanding Diesel Aerial Work Platforms
Diesel industrial aerial platforms depend on fuel-powered engines for operation. Featuring high-endurance, they are great for heavy-duty applications.
Diesel aerial lifts are best used on:
- Construction sites
- Infrastructure projects
- Outdoor industrial facilities
- Rough remote work zones
Key advantages: The power output of diesel platforms is much higher, which allows them to operate for extended periods in a single run. It also makes them more suited for tasks that require lifting heavier loads. Since the need for charging is eliminated, machines running on diesel can be used in remote or undeveloped jobsites that do not have the infrastructure required for charging platforms.
Limitations: When it comes to drawbacks, diesel industrial platforms can get quite noisy. Their emissions are also significantly higher. Both of these factors combined make them an unfit choice for indoor use or highly sensitive areas.
What Are The Differences Between Electric & Diesel Powered Aerial Work Platforms?
The major areas of difference between electric and diesel-powered industrial aerial platforms have been covered below so that operators can make an informed choice:
Work environment
Electric platforms have been purpose-built for safe use in indoor and enclosed environments. As for diesel machines, they are best suited to outdoor use.
Noise and emissions
If a worksite requires controlled emissions and noise levels, electric models should be the default choice. However, less sensitive sites that prioritize muscle power should opt for diesel variations.
Power and performance
Diesel platforms provide extended use along with greater lifting capacity, which makes them perfect for heavy-duty use and remote working conditions. Meanwhile, electric platforms offer greater movement control and efficiency, making them ideal for precise tasks such as installation and maintenance.
Runtime and availability
Dependent on batteries for their functioning, electric models may require downtime for charging. Diesel models provide continuous operation as long as there is available fuel.
How To Choose Between Diesel & Electric Aerial Work Platforms
We recommend choosing electric models for indoor work environments that demand minimal noise and emissions, have supporting charging infrastructure, and concern themselves with installation or maintenance work.
Diesel models should be chosen for outdoor tasks that require high power, continuous operation, and the ability to work on rough terrain.
Conclusion
Between electric and diesel aerial work platforms, the better choice depends on the working conditions of the task or project at hand. Both can be excellent choices if operators play to their individual strengths. That said, choosing models that balance safety and reach is critical, irrespective of the lift’s engine type.
Platform Basket Canada manufactures the safest and most efficient industrial aerial platforms in Ontario. Made for varying work conditions, our electric and diesel machines are adaptive, flexible, and capable of handling a variety of tasks. Contact us to learn more about our aerial lifts and their strengths.
FAQs
Do electric aerial platforms require special charging infrastructure?
Yes. Specific models may require dedicated charging points depending on the type of battery used and its capacity.
Are diesel platforms more expensive as far as maintenance is concerned?
Diesel is an expensive fuel, and diesel-based engines might have more complex maintenance needs, which may contribute to slightly higher bills.
Can electric aerial platforms be used outdoors?
Yes, they can be. However, their suitability for outdoor use entirely depends on the weather and the terrain of the specified work zone.
